Wednesday, June 11, 2014

Fraser Surrey Docks and Coal



Ah, where to start on this one. With the planned coal port expansion at Fraser Surrey Docks, the capacity of Port Metro increases to 59 million (yes million) tonnes per year making it the largest coal exporter in America.

And my fear is that this is not all it wants. There is a desire on the part of the American producers to ship as much as 6 times the presently planned 3 trains per day. 6 TIMES! 18-1+mile long trains coming through the Delta area, White Rock and Burns Bog. This will no doubt become a reality when the Massey Tunnel is removed. (http://www.google.ca/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=1&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0CBwQFjAA&url=http%3A%2F%2Fengage.gov.bc.ca%2Fmasseytunnel%2F&ei=4uSYU8OOGJHqoASVioL4Dg&usg=AFQjCNHhdqbOhl99z9QUWWY4D2pnAv4pkw&sig2=nY7vaSgpTlXUsHtMYZ1Iwg&bvm=bv.68911936,d.cGU)  The channel depth is only an issue at the tunnel. By removing the tunnel the boats can be loaded without the present set-up which requires barging the coal to Texada Island to load onto a ship.

This coal is a softer coal than the coal presently being shipped from the Roberts Bank Coal Terminal (http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Powder_River_Basin). It is problematic for that reason and a real health and safety concern (http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Coal_exports_from_ports_on_the_west_coast_of_Canada_and_the_United_States). As a result at least two American terminals have refused to handle this material. This puts it right in line with the way Mr. Harper is handling all environmental issues; ie, what environmental issues?(http://www.desmog.ca/2013/10/16/canadian-taxpayers-fund-harper-s-65-000-keystone-xl-advertising-trip) And, as we know, Port Metro Vancouver is a Federal Crown Corporation which basically has no accountability (even though they are mandated with decision-making responsibilities under section 67 of Canadian Environmental Assessment Act, 2012). They perform a number of "Habitat Enhancement" Programs in the hopes of being seen as an environmentally friendly group that deserves to have their way with the environment. Sadly what they are proposing for Terminal 2 and enlarging the capacity of the Fraser Surrey Docks is less than good for the Fraser or the Delta area (“Having looked at the document (environmental assessment), it does not meet what we consider the very basic requirements of a health impacts assessment,” Dr. Patricia Daly, Vancouver Coastal Health Authority chief medical health officer, told the Vancouver Sun). And has anybody actually explained how few jobs the coal is creating? And, oh, have I mentioned before that they have taken on no responsibility for the dismantling of the tunnel for their purposes? You and I, BC, will be paying for that.

As a result chief medical health officers of the regional health authorities, have demanded a comprehensive assessment of the environmental impacts. However, Mayor Louis Jackson is -typically- deferring to "more information from staff" before they join other Municipalities (including Metro Vancouver and Surrey) who have also asked for the assessment. Is it that difficult to believe the healthcare professionals know what they are asking for; is it that unreasonable to assume that the assessment should be done by an independent third party? I appreciate that Mayor Jackson does not want to have a rubber stamp council, but really; just what did she learn on her fact finding mission to Norway? Or is this just a continuation of her recent comment that Delta is "Open for Business."

Yes this does sound like a bit of a rant. But then....if Port Metro is not doing its due diligence, who can we hold responsible or accountable?  The Federal Minister of Transport, the Honourable Lisa Rait seems to have given tfhe Port free reign and has not gotten involved in the discussion. Neither has the BC government of Christy Clark gotten involved. I guess we can only hope that the staff at Delta comes up with the necessary information to join the other Municipalities in asking for a full and independent environmental assessment.

The next -and last- comment here is more a question. How is it when this issue is not settled that the BNSF railway is doubling its rail line?(http://www.vickihuntington.ca/content/bnsf-railway-extension-needs-federal-review-huntington) for this contentious coal? Is there something we don't know?

Monday, June 9, 2014

The Massey Tunnel


On the same theme as the last blog entry, this letter was sent to the board of Metro Vancouver. Metro is concerned with Regional Planning and at first blush Mayor Jackson of Delta was the only Mayor in favour of the bridge.
 
I was interested to read that Mayor Louis Jackson was actively courting the Provincial Government for THE BRIDGE last week. And, that the Provincial Government is actively pursuing the construction design phase.

Mayor Jackson is, I believe, the only mayor in Metro Vancouver who supports this BRIDGE and the dismantling of the Massey Tunnel. And yet, the Provincial Government will have us believe that this is the option that is not only the best option, it is the popular one. That is to say that the bridge is the choice that came from public input.

What has been lost in this debate is the fact that Port Metro Vancouver wants the tunnel dismantled so that bigger ships can be handled and port capacity can increase. Until this topic was raised, the dismantling of the Massey tunnel was not an option.

So why is it that British Columbia taxpayers and Metro residents (through road taxes yet to be determined) are going to be paying for Port Metro’s desire to have the tunnel removed? Port Metro is under Federal jurisdiction. It seems that they are pushing our Provincial Government into a decision that is not the choice for Metro Vancouver. We only need to look at the traffic patterns and the growth in traffic at the border, the port, and the region to see that this is also a very questionable choice for placement of a bridge. It does little to redirect traffic away from the Richmond/Vancouver corridor nor does it really allow for traffic growth to circumvent Vancouver.

This all begs the question, why are we paying for this need of Port Metro to have the tunnel removed? And, more importantly why are we even considering this alternative? An appropriately placed bridge and maintaining the tunnel would solve all of those issues. And do it in an economically feasible way. To suggest that THE BRIDGE is the only way to handle the public transportation requirements is just irresponsible.

Port Metro’s desire to increase shipping traffic is a separate issue that needs to be addressed by the Federal Government. The cost for this and the affect on Regional Infrastructure needs to be accounted for. Mayor Jackson has the untenable position of supporting THE BRIDGE option. Neither the Federal Government nor Port Metro have suggested that they would pay for any of the costs while being the only ones that would benefit. From a planning perspective this choice is just plain wrong! We need to put pressure on Metro Vancouver and the Provincial Government to change direction on this issue. If we are going to pay for a bridge let it be the right choice in the right location. And let it be a choice that will enhance our regional planning.

The Massey Tunnel


This letter was sent to the ministry of Transportation and Infrastructure and various news outlets as well as (MLA) Vicky Huntington on May 7, 2014. The only one to respond was Vicky Huntington. The letter points out the Massey Tunnel is far from being obsolete. Like the South Fraser Perimeter road we can plan for something far better and far less costly. It is truly amazing that this bridge is planned for this location with the demolition of the tunnel for no other reason than the desires of Port Metro Vancouver.

This letter is regarding the replacement of the Massey Tunnel. There is real concern in this region that this project is one to finance Port Metro’s desires to have more access to the North Delta harbor and that it has little to do with dealing with the REAL traffic issues of the region. The issues of increased traffic in the Richmond corridor has been minimized by your department. Never has your department shown any real data to convince anyone that this is actually true. It would be really beneficial to see this data. As well, for future growth, why is the issue of taking border traffic away from the city not addressed by this elaborate and expensive plan. Surely a bridge placed further East and avoiding Richmond and the Oak street corridor makes more sense than adding to the traffic in this congested area.

It is clear that “the (tunnel) needs are just for stabilizing the ground and replacing operating systems. If it’s found that the “tube,” the tunnel structure, can remain sound, the rest is only renovation”.  replacement of the tunnel is unwarranted. The tunnel, like the Oakland tunnel of a similar design built in 1928 will remain more than satisfactory and cost effective for many years. “The Massey Tunnel is most like the tunnel under the Maas River in Rotterdam that was completed 17 years earlier by the same Danish engineering firm. After renovation last year, it (is) doing fine”. So why are we going to the expense of dismantling the tunnel when it can work in tandem with a bridge in another location and be far more effective and far less costly? And why, has Port Metro not been a part of this discussion when in reality it is the only reason that the removal of the tunnel is being considered. Surely we can do better in planning infrastructure than planning around the Port’s needs. If the Port’s needs are so prevalent why are they not a part of the negotiation and why are they not footing ANY part of the bill?

 Peter van der Velden

Tsawwassen

Ok, one last time


I had naively thought the issue was over only to find that the rhetoric is not.  So, please, allow me to add my voice to the fray.  This letter to the editor was sent to the Delta Optimist and not published.

I have never argued that the Southlands Development didn’t have interesting aspects to it. Aspects that would appeal to a good part of the community. I have always argued that this explosive issued needed to be handled in a transparent fashion and that there be no hidden agendas. Such was not the case. It really started with Mayor Jackson holding an in-camera (closed doors) session where she suggested to the developer that Delta would “entertain a proposal of 900 units”. Right after she cancelled a public hearing that largely did not support the development. Surely after that there was never really any doubt which way the decision was going to go.

What I would remind people of in the whole of this process is this: Is this the type of governance we want at the Municipal level? This council spent almost a quarter of a million dollars (Yes, $247,000) propping up and supporting this proposal before they spent another $99,000 on a public hearing. A hearing to, what, convince us that they hadn’t made up their minds? Would they have walked away from that $345,525 investment if enough people stood up and said “no”? Not likely. So why even bother with the public hearing when all this continued to do is divide the community. Let me ask all of you in our community: How can ANY decision so divisive be a good decision?

It is painfully obvious that the ramifications of this decision will not go away. The way our council has handled it from the start has pitted people against each other rather than create an environment of trust and co-operation. To have Mayor Jackson naively state that “now the community can heal” shows to what extent she is totally unaware of what her leadership has led this community to.

It was suggested by a columnist in this paper that the whole council would change if Mayor Jackson were to decide not to run again. Whether that is the case or not I certainly hope our next council has the ability to manage the rift Mayor Jackson has created. If not we could be in for a long 4 year term. Just think, the next four years will be pivotal in this community’s well being. We have a 1.5 Million sqft mall on our doorstep, we have Port Metro wanting not just a second berth but the dismantling of our tunnel (at our expense) for more and bigger ships and coal to come up the Fraser. All these will be completed or at least started in the next term as will the bridge. We need strong representation at the Metro board and we need a council that will step up to the plate for our Community. The present council has given me little faith that we will be cared for in this period of growth. And faith is what we need in this period of change.

Peter van der Velden

Tsawwassen

Dedication of the Fraser Perimeter Road

This letter to the editor speaks about the dedication of the new Fraser Perimeter Road. It dates back to July of 2013, just after the Provincial election. Strangely enough Vicky Huntington was not invited to this meeting eventhough she represents this constituency.
 
Well, here we are again it seems. The recent meeting with transportation minister Todd Stone, Mayor Jackson and Scott Hamilton at first glance would seem innocent enough.

However, notwithstanding Mayor Jackson’s comments, the Province of BC (ie the taxpayers of BC, not the Liberal Party) has put sufficient funds toward this project to warrant the presence of both local MLA’s, not just Mayor Jackson’s choice. Mayor Jackson states that this is up to Province. If she truly were a ‘leader’ of this community and honestly be interested in appropriate presentation she would see this as her responsibility. This is not just a case of ‘appropriate policy’ but a matter of decency. Mayor Jackson apparently doesn’t understand this and finds the need to label the response as an act of conspiracy. I guess when you are in her position for as long as she it might be difficult to differentiate (and I’ll quote Mayor Jackson) acts of courtesy and ”trouble visits”. Especially when you are so very busy.

I’m afraid this brings me to an older theme. It is very clear that Scott Hamilton in his mere weeks as a newly elected MLA has shown an inability to act in good faith for the community.  And he is supported in that by Mayor Jackson. It is understandable as they have been aligned for some time. However, it belies any convention and common sense. No-one can serve two masters. Whether one is on an “unpaid leave of absence” (-with voting rights ??!) or just showing up when you can (or by phone), both positions require one’s full and unbiased attention. Not only do the people of North Delta deserve a dedicated MLA,  the people of all of Delta deserve a full and attentive council. Similar comments have been made for all other constituencies that are in this predicament. For any council to obscure this issue with comments about cost is an avoidance of democracy and hides whatever real reasons exist.  It is really clear that the above issue merely presents the tip of the iceberg. This problem will only get worse if it is not attended to now. There will be conflict of interest on almost all issues, provincial and municipal! One of the first things they teach you on council is that if it may appear as a conflict, it is a conflict. Mayor Jackson and Mr. Hamilton seem to have forgotten that.

Please, anyone that cares about this issue write to this council and tell them to get on with a by-election! Only a year ago Mayor Jackson was telling us that the cost for council was low and that most cities of this size need more than 6 councilors to do the work. Let’s get the council we deserve.

Politics; survival of the fattest



This caricature is something that came to me some time ago when a number of issues came up around MLA Expenses. Although it appears to single out one particular person it really applies to all politicians, Federal, Provincial and Municipal. Anyone should be subject to scrutiny when the lines between reality and fantasy are blurred. A slap on the wrist just doesn't quite cut it when you are in a position of public trust. Anyone elected to office should know better. If they don't they have no right to be in public office.